Skip to main content

Book-To-Movie: ‘Casting the Runes’ and 'Curse of the Demon'

A cartoon of three jack-o-lanterns and four bats.
Credit: Pixabay.com

I've moved our fourth Monday Book-To-Movie (BTM) again, this time to this 5th Monday of October due to the overloaded schedule of the Halloween season. But, so you can get a groovy Halloween post, I made sure to give it to you before October passes us unlike I did with September’s BTM)! A story by the early 20th century British author, M.R. James, such as "Casting the Runes" probably won't ring a death toll bell as does Edgar Allan Poe’s “Fall of the House of Usher”. And unless you’re a big watcher of b-rated movies like me, not even the 1957 movie adaptation of “Casting”, "Curse of the Demon", will even ring much of a bell. Yet both short story and movie are made really good. One of the biggest changes made to the story for the movie is that the monster is actually shown while, yet, not taking too much away from the suspense of the original short story. 


The Short Story: 'Casting the Runes'

"Casting the Runes" is about a committee officer, Dunning, who gets cursed by occultist Karswell whose paper on alchemy he had turned down from being read at a meeting. Out of vengeance, Karswell, slips a parchment of runes in Dunning's possession which brings on an invisible force of evil that terrorises Dunning. The committee man must find a way to return the parchment to Karswell without making it known to him in order to get rid of the unseen demon. 

The demon in this story is described in very abstract terms most of the time because of its invisibility. In fact, it's the feeling of dread on Dunning's part that it's mostly described through rather than through its visage. The closest that we get to seeing a description of the monster is when it’s described biting someone. But often what can't be seen but felt is scarier. It's this holding back of details of the monster that keeps the reader in suspense and puts her more in the terrorised mind of the protagonist. 

The Movie: 'Curse of the Demon'

In this movie, originally titled "Night of the Demon" for its original British version, the protagonist of the short story has been changed from committee man Dunning to skeptical U.S. parapsychologist Holden who goes to England for a convention on the paranormal. Instead of the rejection of a manuscript, the reason for Satanist Karswell slipping Holden the cursed parchment is because the latter attempts to disprove black magic of the former. 

Unlike in the original short story, the demon in “Curse” is revealed, although only twice: once at the beginning and once at the end. According to an article in the October 2019 issue of “Famous Monsters of Filmland”, director Jacques Tourneur and producer Hal E. Chester conflicted over how often the demon should be shown in the film and so how much of the minimalism of the short story should be kept. However, I personally believe that limiting the demon’s appearance to only two points in the film was a good compromise which allowed the mere effects of its attacks to keep the audience in suspense and thinking more about the events of the story. 

I had a couple of problems with the movie, though. One was actually a slight problem where, at one point, the monster grows from its human size to a gargantuan size for no apparent reason. The purpose is likely to have been competition with the atomic giant-monster films that dominated the U.S. cinematic market during that time that this British-made supernatural horror film was distributed to. However, one part of me was okay with it just because I'm biased for giant monsters. Yet, it caused a slight imbalance in the presentation of the story. 

The acting was okay and so was the characterisation. However, Karswell's mom played comic relief too much for this mostly dark film and so, therefore, reducing the horrifying effect it’s supposed to have on its audience. Not that there wasn't a need for comic relief; there definitely was. But it was overdone with the middle-aged Satanist’s mother showing up all the time. 


"Curse of the Demon" works good visually while "Casting the Runes", its source material, works good psychologically. It’s a supernatural horror film that goes good with Halloween because it’s set around that time of year. Yet, it isn't dependent on its Halloween theme and so this makes it good for watching anytime and so doesn't come across as exclusively seasonal like some horror movies do. 



Newsletter

The, slightly, Halloween edition of my author’s newsletter is now out! If you haven’t subscribe to the newsletter then you can do so here. It’s free! 


Be here Wednesday for another Insecure Writer's Support Group (IWSG) blog hop! 

Have you read anything by M.R. James? Have you seen "Curse/Night of the Demon"? Do you know of any other movies out there that are based on an M.R. James' story?

Have a Happy and Safe Halloween!



Comments

  1. Think I'll look for the short story instead.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The story's really good. Probably no movie adaptation can beat it!

      Delete
  2. I've not heard of either. I think featuring the monster only twice in the movie was a good idea. Less is best.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah, and more as they also say (less is more). Sometimes when the monster is revealed too much or too soon it takes away the terror and suspense and in some cases even from other elements of the story.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Book-To-Movie: Stephen King’s 'The Raft'

Credit: Pixabay.com It's the third Saturday of the month and so that means it's time for another Book-To-Movie ! In a Book-To-Movie we review a book and its movie adaptation. One of the reasons I as a horror fan don’t read a lot of Stephen King’s work is because most of it consists of novels that go more than 400 pages. I have a short attention span when it comes to reading, ironically since I consider myself an avid reader, and so I normally won’t read a work that is much more than the equivalent to a 350-page mass market paperback. The other reason why I don’t read a lot of King’s work is that, as literary scholars will tell you, a lot of his writing is poor. However, he does have some good writing in his works, especially his earlier stuff, including his short horror tales. So if I read anything by Stephen King it’s usually his short stories or novellas. One of his collections I’ve read is Skeleton Crew which includes some of his good, or at least

Book-To-Movie: ‘The Hound of the Baskervilles’

Credit: Wikimedia Commons I apologise for posting outside our regular post-day which is late Saturday night/early Sunday morning. However, I got behind on several things last week and so had to postpone the post to today.  I’ve been a reader of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes books ever since I was 11. What I’ve always liked so much about the series is that, like a good horror story, the stories often take place in dark settings and involve bizarre cases. Conan Doyle’s novel, “The Hound of the Baskervilles”, definitely contains these elements. It’s a detective story that crosses over into the gothic horror genre. Several movie adaptations of the novel have been made that go as far back as a 1915 German silent film. In 1959 Hammer Studios released a version starring Peter Cushing and Christopher Lee. As much as I’m a fan of the Hammer horror films, I have not seen that one yet. The only one that I’ve seen so far is the 1939 adaptation starring that other big name in classic Bri

Book-To-Movie: Guest Blogger Alex Cavanaugh Reviews 'Relic'

Credit: Tor Books The fourth weekend of the month, when we normally have our Book-To-Movie review has passed us again. However, the review is still on! This month I have a guest blogger for our Book-To-Movie review. The two of us agreed to trade our book-to-movie reviews and present them to you today, this last Monday of the month. In a Book-To-Movie, we review a work of prose fiction and its movie adaptation.  And my guest blogger and reviewer is Alex Cavanaugh. Alex is the author of the Cassa series  of novels and founder of the Insecure Writers' Support Group ! Here at the Fantastic Site, he’s reviewing a best-selling novel of detective horror, "Relic", and its movie adaptation. In turn, at his site, I have the pleasure of reviewing "The Black Phone" short story by Joe Hill and its movie adaptation. So, after you're finished reading Alex’s awesome review, please leave a comment for him in the box below and then head on over to his website to check out my