Skip to main content

Book-To-Movie: Review of ‘The House With a Clock In Its Walls’

An antique wooden clock reading five-minutes-to-twelve.
Credit: Pixabay.com


Before director Eli Roth adapted it to film, the closest that John Bellair’s YA novel, The House With a Clock In Its Walls, came to a movie was as a short film featured in a made-for-TV Halloween special. That was back in the ‘70s, not too long after the book had released. Entitled Once Upon a Midnight Scary, it was an hour-long anthology featuring three short films, the last being “The House With a Clock In Its Walls”, narrated by Vincent Price who encouraged young viewers to read the books these films were based on. That encouragement definitely worked with me. I saw it when I was around 9 and read House With a Clock when I was about 25. Okay, so that encouragement didn’t work the first time but did work the second time, when I saw the Vincent Price special on VHS. I’ve read the book at least twice and loved it. So when September’s release of the big screen adaptation was announced back in the summer I was like “Yeah! Finally!” Well, I saw The House With a Clock In Its Walls a couple of weeks ago. I wasn’t disappointed. However, viewers, such as myself, who have read the novel may not be as impressed with the terror the film offers as those who haven’t read it. Even so, it still offers plenty of suspense and awe.

House With a Clock released on good timing. It premiered in theatres at the end of September, just in time for the Halloween season and is very Halloween-ish like the book while it doesn’t limit itself to the theme and so is perfect viewing and reading for anytime of the year. As far as story goes, the movie, overall, stays faithful to the book. Lewis moves in with his Uncle Johnathan after his parents have passed away and soon discovers a deadly secret in his uncle’s creepy but fascinating mansion. The secret is connected with a strange, loud ticking of a clock that is hidden somewhere in the house and that his uncle and their neighbour and friend Mrs. Zimmerman are desperately trying to uncover. However, after Lewis gets a hold of a necromancy book he accidently raises from the dead the evil husband and wife magicians, Isaac and Selena (“Serenna” in the novel) Izard, who had hidden the clock and now try to drive Johnathan and Lewis out of the house. But Johnathan, Lewis and Mrs. Zimmerman won’t give up without a fight, literally.

Jack Black plays his role as Johnathan Barnavelt really good and comes across as the eccentric that the character does in the book. Owen Vacarro who plays Lewis isn’t bad but the development of the character in the movie could have been made with a better emotional connection to the audience like it is in the novel. Cate Blanchett plays good the part of Mrs. Zimmerman especially in relation to Johnathan with the light-hearted humour of condescending remarks the two characters toss back and forth to each other which is also shown in the book.

Unlike in the novel, Isaac Izard plays a larger and more present role in the film than his wife, Selena, does. In the book, the emphasis was the other way around between these two characters. Even though he is out-right menacing in his haggard features, in this film Selena isn’t that menacing in her appearance like she is in the book. She is much younger than he (or at least appears to be, witches can disguise themselves, right?) and made up to meet society’s standards of beauty but, still, she is just as evil in her actions and demeanor as she is in the novel. (Think Wilhelmina in ABC’s Ugly Betty, if you ever watched that sitcom, only more occultic.)

An addition to the movie is that Lewis is trained as a wizard by his uncle much more than he is in the book. Maybe this was added to compete with the Harry Potter films and their more recent brainchild, Fantastic Beasts. Even so, this addition to Lewis’s character works.

As I said, people who have read the novel won’t be as struck by the frightful scenes as much as those who haven’t read it. Still, the movie as a whole mesmerises. Both the surrealism of Johnathan’s house and the magic that it holds, such as changing images in stained glass windows and a living chair, will amuse audiences. Also the black magic of the Izards will do the same and hold viewers in suspense. The Izards even take their magic further than they do in the book when they launch a horde of monsters against the good magicians.

A few elements in the movie may make it questionable whether it’s suitable for family viewing. Some of the crude humour is a little overdone although it doesn’t ruin the rest of the film like with too many movies made for younger audiences. However, as in the book, the occult is referenced a lot which may make this film not suitable for children under the age of 8. It’s hard to say because only parents know their own kids best. Or they should.


I have to admit, not even the movie adaptation of The House With a Clock In Its Walls with it’s awe-inspiring special effects and fantastical, gothic settings can do justice to the book. The book had more going on in it and looks further into the characters’ lives and psychs than the movie. In fact, compared to the book, the events of the movie are kind of rushed. But, overall, the big screen adaptation interprets the novel well and still amuses and offers plenty of suspense. I hope to see a sequel since the book had two of them. But I also hope this movie will encourage kids and even adults who have not read the novel to read it.

Until next time . . . 



Coming Soon to Amazon!


Now Available at Amazon!



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Book-To-Movie: Stephen King’s 'The Raft'

Credit: Pixabay.com It's the third Saturday of the month and so that means it's time for another Book-To-Movie ! In a Book-To-Movie we review a book and its movie adaptation. One of the reasons I as a horror fan don’t read a lot of Stephen King’s work is because most of it consists of novels that go more than 400 pages. I have a short attention span when it comes to reading, ironically since I consider myself an avid reader, and so I normally won’t read a work that is much more than the equivalent to a 350-page mass market paperback. The other reason why I don’t read a lot of King’s work is that, as literary scholars will tell you, a lot of his writing is poor. However, he does have some good writing in his works, especially his earlier stuff, including his short horror tales. So if I read anything by Stephen King it’s usually his short stories or novellas. One of his collections I’ve read is Skeleton Crew which includes some of his good, or at least...

Book-To-Movie: ‘The Hound of the Baskervilles’

Credit: Wikimedia Commons I apologise for posting outside our regular post-day which is late Saturday night/early Sunday morning. However, I got behind on several things last week and so had to postpone the post to today.  I’ve been a reader of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes books ever since I was 11. What I’ve always liked so much about the series is that, like a good horror story, the stories often take place in dark settings and involve bizarre cases. Conan Doyle’s novel, “The Hound of the Baskervilles”, definitely contains these elements. It’s a detective story that crosses over into the gothic horror genre. Several movie adaptations of the novel have been made that go as far back as a 1915 German silent film. In 1959 Hammer Studios released a version starring Peter Cushing and Christopher Lee. As much as I’m a fan of the Hammer horror films, I have not seen that one yet. The only one that I’ve seen so far is the 1939 adaptation starring that other big name in classic...

Book-To-Movie: Guest Blogger Alex Cavanaugh Reviews 'Relic'

Credit: Tor Books The fourth weekend of the month, when we normally have our Book-To-Movie review has passed us again. However, the review is still on! This month I have a guest blogger for our Book-To-Movie review. The two of us agreed to trade our book-to-movie reviews and present them to you today, this last Monday of the month. In a Book-To-Movie, we review a work of prose fiction and its movie adaptation.  And my guest blogger and reviewer is Alex Cavanaugh. Alex is the author of the Cassa series  of novels and founder of the Insecure Writers' Support Group ! Here at the Fantastic Site, he’s reviewing a best-selling novel of detective horror, "Relic", and its movie adaptation. In turn, at his site, I have the pleasure of reviewing "The Black Phone" short story by Joe Hill and its movie adaptation. So, after you're finished reading Alex’s awesome review, please leave a comment for him in the box below and then head on over to his website to check out my...